I really need to stop being lazy and update this thing more frequently. Looking back at my last post, it really does seem like ages ago that I was trying that Clipper. Since then, I’ve decided to give that blade away to my friend (who loves it and needs it more than I do), and go back to the much harder Xiom V1. The Clipper is undoubtedly a great blade, but I think the softness makes pip blocking less effective (albeit easier), because it becomes more inverted-like. By that, I mean that the softness gives it more dwell time, and thus less deadening effect. In the end, I figured that since it made my pips behave pretty much like a weak smooth rubber, it’s better off with my friend who actually uses smooth. Speaking of which, his combination is now that Clipper with BW2 and HPB, and it’s absolutely amazing. Crazy spin, more than enough speed, and a great feel. Additionally, the weight distribution works out well, and the blade doesn’t feel heavy, even with the super heavy BW2 on it.
Speaking of BW2, that is the main point of this post. I’ll get back to everything else afterwards. I got an email about a new and improved BW2, which has a red sponge (instead of black) and is supposed to be lighter. Sounds like a dream come true (although I really liked the black sponge). So, since I had to order some other stuff (a new sheet of Spectol, and a sheet of Haifu Penguin for a friend, which I will write about if I ever get around to trying it), I just had to get myself a sheet of this (theoretically) perfect rubber. Well, it came in this Monday, and it indeed has a red sponge (which is pretty cool, and I expect it would make the red version look super thick), and it’s certainly lighter than the old version. I ordered a black sheet in 39 degrees, which is the same hardness as I’m used to, although it has been a long time since I actually played with the BW2. On my V1 (with Spectol on the BH), the weight was very manageable, and I didn’t feel my arm speed decrease or my wrist strain in more than with the H3. I think it’s still heavier than H3, maybe around the same as Tenergy, but definitely a significant decrease in weight from the old one. However, I think that this “new” BW2 might be something like a rebranded Grip-S, as it resembles the Grip-S much more than it does BW2. First of all, the topsheet is completely different, both in feel and in appearance. I think it’s thinner, softer, and shinier, and pretty much looks exactly like the Grip-S topsheet. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, because at the same time, the quality went way up. There were no visual blemishes (this is the first sheet of BW2 I’ve EVER seen without some markings), and it I think the softer topsheet gives it a bit more dwell time. However, aside from that, I have to say that I like the old topsheet more, because the stiffness (and tackiness — the new one can’t pick the ball up) made the rubber feel more Chinese. This new BW2 had the same super high throw (maybe even higher, if that’s possible), and is pretty insanely fast. I think it’s faster than the original, but loses some in the spin department, although the spin is still monstrous, unlike any other rubber I’ve tried. It’s a little difficult to describe, but I would say that the old BW2 is closer to H3, while the new one is closer to Tenergy. I still got the problem of it expanding like crazy after the second gluing, and I already peeled off the tuning layer (which is still VERY thick) after testing it out because I felt that I didn’t need the extra speed/weight. Honestly, it might be because I didn’t get to try it enough the first day, but taking off the tuning didn’t detract from the rubber in any way. It helped me glue it on since it domed much less (oh yeah, it domes like crazy straight out of the package, and wouldn’t stay glued on the blade when I first tried it), and made it lighter overall. Actually, while there is very little difference with and without the tuning layer on this BW2, there was a much bigger difference with the old version. It used to be that the tuned version felt more like a “hybrid” type rubber (as in, not classic Chinese feeling), and the untuned one felt pretty Chinese. I guess the new topsheet (and sponge) makes this new version feel softer overall without the need for tuning. Definitely not a bad thing with my V1 (which is super hard).
Anyway, I’ve written all this stuff about it, but what about playing with it? The high throw definitely threw me off at first, and I’m still adjusting to it. However, there is no doubt that my opening loops are spinnier than they are with H3. I think it’s also the fact that I don’t look like I’m putting a lot of effort into creating spin (and that’s the truth — I really don’t have to force it), so the opponents think it’s a light loop, when in reality it’s pretty loaded. Counterlooping and overall mid distance play is pretty stable, as long as I remember to close the blade accordingly. I do feel like I have to hold back a little to keep the ball from going too long, but I think that’s just temporary until I get used to the trajectory of the rubber. The short game seems to be fine, although I’ve been missing many balls due to timing errors… so maybe that’s the weight difference. Lastly, my serves are apparently quite a bit spinnier than before, as people have been dumping the underspin into the net several times in a row. Again, I think it’s a difference in the perceived spin and actual spin, because this rubber produces some crazy spin without much effort (like Tenergy). Of course, it’s also quite sensitive to incoming spin, and I’ve had to really watch out when I play passive balls, because while the H3 would deaden the ball, the BW2 just eats it up. In conclusion, if you like Grip-S, this new BW2 is the new and improved version, being both lighter and harder. I really hope I can adjust to the throw angle and continue using this. Even though I’m still not “at home” with this rubber like I am with H3, I think it looks awesome and I really like how much spin I can get (especially on sidespin loops!), so I would like to use it as long as possible!
All right, so now that the main story is finished, here are some other random updates on equipment. I tried my friend’s sheet of Stiga Radical, and I really like some aspects of it. Namely, I love how it can deaden the ball so easily. It is by far the best short pip I’ve used for this purpose, by several orders of magnitude. Even a super powerful loop can be returned dead and short with ease — it’s amazing! And hitting with it produces a very fast, but super dead ball, which is almost impossible to attack back. The downside is that it’s not really capable of producing anything other than a dead ball, and while I can get some spin with it (since it’s sticky), the spin is minimal, and inconsistent. It’s also very difficult to practice with it, since I can’t really keep the ball on the table, and neither can my practice partner! It’s just a mess. Also, this means that pushing with it basically always produces an easily attacked ball, so speed and positioning of the push become extremely important. Anyway, I really wanted to give it a try in 1.8 (the sheet I borrowed is 2.0 and too thick for my taste), but the local TT store didn’t have 1.8 red in stock, so I went with the Stiga Royal, which they recommended, saying it had similar spin characteristics. Well, they don’t. The Royal is a good pip in its own right, and easily the most beautiful sheet of short pips I’ve ever seen. It’s a gorgeous translucent red, and the minimalist label looks awesome on a short pip (but it would look a little lame on a smooth rubber). Interestingly, the sponge is grey, and I have suspicions that it’s the same sponge as Almana, because that’s the only other rubber I’ve ever seen with a grey sponge. Anyway, the Royal is FAST, but in terms of spin, it’s basically the exact opposite of the Radical, and much more resembles the Clippa (a very, very spinny short pip). The sponge is fairly soft, so when I smacked straight through the ball (so I could really hit into the wood), it produced a very fast dead ball, which is great. However, the Royal is fairly spinny otherwise, so unless I hit very hard to bottom out the sponge, there was no way to really produce a good dead ball. Also, the angle required to push and block were a little strange, and although that’s just an adjustment thing, I didn’t see enough advantages to commit to the change. Thus, I ended up going back to my trusty Spectol, the tried and true do-it-all short pip. Now I see why people say they try to switch but always end up going back. It might just be because I’m used to it, but I can do “everything” with the Spectol, even though it doesn’t stand out in any aspect. I think if the store ever gets the Radical in stock, I may commit some time to using it, because I think there’s a lot of potential there, but until then, I still love my Spectol the most.
Actually, there is one pip that might be really good, and that’s Hammond FA. My friend gave me a free (used) sheet to try (in 2.0), and I glued it on my MJ to test out. I wasn’t expecting much, but it can actually produce pretty good dead balls when hitting, but at the same time, it makes great spin when you spin with it. The pips feel very hard and dry (if that makes any sense), but I was able to do pretty much a real loop with it. As a harder pip, control becomes more of an issue, but maybe I should actually give it a shot. Also in experimental rubbers, I got a sheet of DHS Memo 3 and tested it on my V1 for a bit. Definitely not a bad rubber, especially for the price. It has a pretty fierce reverse dome, so gluing is a bit of a pain, but it has decent spin and speed. The best way to describe it would be “taut,” in the sense that the topsheet seemed to be pulled very tight (which it clearly isn’t, judging by the reverse dome). It just feels like you can get a lot of power when you hit the ball very hard but it becomes more difficult to do slower brush loops. It’s really not a bad rubber at all, and I think many people who are used to Euro rubbers but want something that feels more direct would really like it. It does have a very direct and linear feel to it, so while it’s fast, it’s not “free” power like tensors. I would recommend it as a FH rubber for those that don’t like H3 and other related rubbers (tacky topsheet and hard/dead sponge). However, it really didn’t offer me anything that I couldn’t already get from the H3, so I didn’t stick with it (duh, since I’m using the BW2 now).
Ok! I guess that’s it for now. Wow that was long. Oh yeah, last weekend I went up to Bellevue for a small tournament (I only played doubles). It was pretty fun, but nothing really exciting. I’m hoping to play in the next tournament here, which is about 6 weeks away. I’ll talk about that when the time comes.
Continue reading →