This doesn’t have anything to do with ping pong, but I also happen to be a big fan of musicals, and I went to see Jesus Christ Superstar tonight. Although I’ve seen both movies (I’m pretty sure there are only two), and listen to the soundtrack often, I’ve never had a chance to see it performed live… until now! I’m not really sure what to write about overall impressions, so I’m just going to go through my program and write what I thought as I watched the show.
Actually, I lied. There are some general impressions I had about the overall style of the show. First and foremost, Ted Neeley (who played Jesus in the old movie) was Jesus in this cast, and I’m really surprised at what his voice can still do at his age. Aside from him, the cast was relatively unexperienced (based on what they wrote in the program), but their voices were all fantastic. Lastly, the instrumentation has changed. I would say that this production was more of a musical, and less of a rock opera, if that makes any sense. The score was more new age (although it’s still very close to the original score), and on many of the songs, there were some harmonies that reminded me of a capella (thanks to watching Sing-Off). Overall, I liked the change. It felt a little more upbeat, and the harmonies were richer. However, it is, I think, detrimental to the mood, so maybe there should be a balance between the original versions and this new version. Anyway, now onto the specifics.
The overture was very different from both the movies, so it was very unexpected for me. Simon (I think) got stabbed by this roman guard, and then Jesus came in and resurrected him. Oh yeah, when Jesus comes onto the stage (or when he has a solo part), there are all these lights that make him seem godly. I thought it was pretty funny, but I liked it. Moving on… Judas was a great singer. The show really can’t be good if Judas isn’t good. I actually liked his voice more than either one of the movies, but he didn’t have quite the range of the others. In general, the singers in this production had more “modern” voices… smoother, richer, not so much traditional broadway.
The arrangement for “Everything’s Alright” was interesting, and I thought it was better than the original version. When Mary sings “…try not to turn onto problem that upset you, oh,” that “oh” is actually sung by everyone else, and sounds very fun and upbeat. I almost laughed when I first heard it, because it made the song sound so lighthearted. Also, the song ends with everyone singing one note and then cutting it off cleanly, instead of fading away, which I liked, because I always thought it went on a little too long the old way.
Caiaphas and Annas had their traditional voices, with Caiaphas being really low and Annas being really high. However, throughout the show, Caiaphas’s voice kept changing! Sometimes it would go higher (as in, not super duper low), and then suddenly change to the really low voice. I’m not sure why… but I think it would’ve been better if he kept it really low the whole time.
Simon had a really great voice, but the background singers drowned him out a bit in his song. Also, it’s very different from the second movie. In the movie, his song comes after he and the other followers get into a fight with the police or whatever they are. In this production, they all hid while the guards came around, and then came out to sing this song after the guards had left, which I thought was very ironic (they left Jesus there all alone and hid away, then they come out and sing about how much they love him). To me, it makes more sense to put the fight in there, since it can then follow by singing about how Jesus could become so powerful.
When Jesus arrived in Jerusalem was when I realized Ted Neeley still had it. Wow, is all I can say. Pilate was good, but not exceptional. I don’t really know what to say. He pulled off his part, but didn’t really make an impression either way. “The Temple” was done very well, since I hadn’t seen it on stage before. Sounds weird, but all the cripples and whatever begging for Jesus’s help reminded me of the hollows in Bleach. However, they drowned out Jesus, so I couldn’t really hear what he was saying (if I weren’t familiar with the lyrics, I would’ve had no idea at all).
I really liked Mary’s voice, simply because it wasn’t as squeaky (nasal-sounding) as many of the broadway women I’ve heard. I also liked the way this song (I don’t know how to love him) was done. Very direct, and a little faster than usual (I always felt like this song dragged on a little). Plus, the instrumentation was a little more upbeat, with some new-age piano.
The Last Supper was funny because right before Jesus starts singing (right after the main chorus), they all freeze in the pose of the famous painting. Other than that, nothing was really noteworthy. Gethsemane, I hate to say, was a bit of a disappointment. I really love this song, and as much as I’m impressed by Ted Neeley’s voice, I hate his phrasing, which I’d describe as a severe rubato. He always slows down until he’s a phrase behind the orchestra, and stays that way for a very long time, until finally catching up really fast at the end. There is a place for rubato, but this is way too extreme, and just leaves you feeling very uncomfortable. The rhythm is all wrong, and the music just doesn’t have the same impact that it should. That being said, his voice is still incredible.
I hadn’t really heard Peter sing until his denial, and he had a really, really great voice. Very smooth. The problem is that in this particular show, there really isn’t much of a place for that kind of voice. He would do very well in other shows though. Looking at his credits, he played Judas before (I could see that), and also Freddie from Chess (hard role!). Another funny moment was the beginning of the scene with Herod. Herod is unaware that Jesus was brought there, so when he turned around, he was shocked and screamed “Jesus!” Thought that was pretty clever. His performance was quite good, and was very true to the role. The 4 backup singer girls were very good at the accompaniment, as well.
Now, strangely enough, “Could we start again, please” was the one song that impressed me the most throughout this performance. Well, ok, it might not have been the best, but it was the most improved, I think, when comparing to the other performances I’ve seen/heard. They really used richer harmonies, and the whole thing sounded very full and much more colorful than the original version. This isn’t a really important song, and there was virtually no choreography or anything, but they really did a good job with this one.
“Superstar” was good because Judas was good. The only complaint here (once again) is that they didn’t balance the microphones very well. Judas got drowned out occasionally, which is really a shame. Lastly, the end was very strange, and very long (Jesus suffering before he died). I’m not really sure why the show ends with John 19:41, as it leaves sort of a bad taste in your mouth, so to speak. In fact, now that I think about it, maybe it would’ve been better to put “Superstar” at the very end. You just very rarely see musicals that end unmusically.
Anyway, that’s about it. This was a great experience for me, and I think if I had the chance to see another cast do this, I would go. It’s really a great musical. Next up is Lion King in June! I can’t wait.